Hash: SHA1

The Trial Testimony of Greg Jones, Day 2, SCO v. Novell

,----[ Qupte ]
| We learn two primary things from Jones' testimony: first, what a cynical role
| Sun played in the SCO saga, and second, that all the time SCO was calling on
| the world, the courts, the Congress -- nay heaven itself, if I may say so --
| to sympathize with it over the ruination of its Most Holy Intellectual
| Property by it being improperly open sourced into Linux, not that it turned
| out to be true, it had already secretly given Sun the right to open source it
| in OpenSolaris. Remember all that falderol about SCO being contractually
| unable to show us the code, much as it so desired to do so, because of being
| bound to confidentiality requirements? What a farce. SCO had already secretly
| given Sun the right to open source Solaris, with all the UNIX System V you
| can eat right in there.
| The simple fact is, I gather from Jones' testimony, Sun could have prevented
| the harm SCO sought to cause by simply telling us what rights it had
| negotiated and received from SCO prior to SCO launching its assault on Linux.
| Yet it remained silent. When I consider all folks were put through, all the
| unnecessary litigation, and all the fear and the threats and the harmful
| smears, including of me at the hands of SCO and all the dark little helper
| dwarves in SCO's workshop, I feel an intense indignation like a tsunami
| toward Sun for remaining silent.


Sorry Simon, but you’re still screwing up

,----[ Quote ]
| But he isolates the “screw-up” to 2001-2002, when Sun was still a proprietary
| company. This is like a candidate for re-election blaming the problems he
| faces on a predecessor from the other party.
| The fact is Sun is still screwing up. Offering open source licenses for key
| products is not all there is to an open source strategy. Transparency,
| community, and some ceding of authority are also required.



Sun: We screwed up on open source

,----[ Quote ]
| Many open source developers remain sceptical of Sun because their memories of
| the company focus on Sun's interactions with the community in 2001/2002,
| which Sun's chief open source officer Simon Phipps concedes was a period
| where Sun "screwed up".
| [...]
| "We've open sourced Java [...] and people see that and they say 'wow, you've
| GPLed Java, you must be serious!'

Version: GnuPG v1.4.6 (GNU/Linux)